Day 12: In the Name of Those Who Spoke
My family was lucky, half of the them survived.
I don't understand the Holocaust. I dare not presume to ascribe meaning to a depth of human suffering I have no comprehension of. So I am silent.
But my great grandmother is dead, so are her sisters and brother. They can no longer speak.
So should I be silent? Dare I be silent?
Of what should I speak?
- That man may be reduced to an animal.
- Lest we forget.
- Of being numbered rather than named.
No, there's something better to be said.
One who says an idea in the name of the one who taught it, brings the geulah closer.
So what did my great grandmother, Rivka bat Yehudah, teach me?
To work is good,
to work often is better,
and to work for the good of others, best of all.
So, maybe the geulah is a little closer now.
I don't understand the Holocaust. I dare not presume to ascribe meaning to a depth of human suffering I have no comprehension of. So I am silent.
But my great grandmother is dead, so are her sisters and brother. They can no longer speak.
So should I be silent? Dare I be silent?
Of what should I speak?
- That man may be reduced to an animal.
- Lest we forget.
- Of being numbered rather than named.
No, there's something better to be said.
One who says an idea in the name of the one who taught it, brings the geulah closer.
So what did my great grandmother, Rivka bat Yehudah, teach me?
To work is good,
to work often is better,
and to work for the good of others, best of all.
So, maybe the geulah is a little closer now.

7 Comments:
Thank you for a beautiful post and for giving me at least one clear message to take away from this confusing day.
By
ayala, at 7:33 PM, April 25, 2006
I've spent my whole life trying to comprehend it...
By
David_on_the_Lake, at 10:42 PM, April 25, 2006
I really appreciated your post. I like the end best of all -because you are correct, I believe. You have made the geula nearer by your remembrance, mourning, message, and silence.
By
Okee, at 12:07 AM, April 27, 2006
This post brought a tear to my eye. Beautiful.
By
Eshet Chayil, at 10:55 AM, April 27, 2006
My mother is a holocaust survivor and she told me that throughout the holocaust she just kept asking the same thing over and over again..... Why? Why? Why?
By
A Frum Idealist, at 1:15 PM, April 27, 2006
This really touched my heart. My grandparents lived through the holocaust but they lost their entire families aside from two sisters. My grandparents never spoke about it so I can't say how they felt about it. I know it affected them greatly and they dealt with it in ways I can never understand. At least I have a morsel of positivity coming when reading things like you just wrote. Puts things into some kind of perspective....
By
FrumGirl, at 5:07 PM, April 27, 2006
Touching, my grandmother went through it. Visit my blog.
By
socialworker/frustrated mom, at 9:18 PM, April 27, 2006
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home